Nocatee vs Bannon Lakes: A St. Johns County Comparison (2026)

by Joey Larsen

Nocatee or Bannon Lakes -- how do these St. Johns County communities compare?

Both are St. Johns County communities, but they differ in scale, location, and character. Nocatee is large and amenity-rich near the Ponte Vedra beaches; Bannon Lakes is a smaller community near St. Augustine with convenient access to shopping. Here is how to weigh them.

Quick Answer

Nocatee (32081, near Ponte Vedra) is a large master-planned community with beach proximity, water parks, extensive trails, and a wide price range. Bannon Lakes, near St. Augustine off International Golf Parkway, is a smaller community with its own amenities and convenient access to shopping and I-95. Nocatee suits buyers wanting scale, beach proximity, and deep amenities; Bannon Lakes suits buyers wanting a smaller community with St. Augustine-side convenience.

Location

Nocatee sits in northern St. Johns County near the Ponte Vedra beaches, roughly ten to fifteen minutes from the coast. Bannon Lakes is farther south near St. Augustine, convenient to shopping and I-95 but farther from the northern beaches. Your preference between the Ponte Vedra and St. Augustine sides of the county guides this choice.

Scale and Amenities

Nocatee is large and deeply amenitized, with water parks, a 30-plus-mile Greenway, Town Center, and the preserve. Bannon Lakes is smaller, with its own amenity center and a more compact, convenient feel. If you want the deepest amenity bench, Nocatee leads; if a smaller community with easy shopping access appeals, Bannon Lakes fits.

Big Amenities or Compact Convenience? Let's Compare.

I help buyers weigh Nocatee, Bannon Lakes, and the rest of St. Johns County against their priorities. Let's find the community that fits how you want to live.

Call or text Joey Larsen: 904-863-6679
or visit RetireMeToFlorida.com

Price and Homes

Both offer resale and new construction options. Bannon Lakes' smaller scale and St. Augustine-side location give it a different value profile, while Nocatee spans attainable to estate near the coast. Compare specific homes and their CDD and HOA costs rather than community averages.

Who Each Fits Best

Choose Nocatee if beach proximity, deep amenities, and a wide range of homes matter most. Choose Bannon Lakes if you want a smaller community with St. Augustine-side convenience and shopping access. Both are solid St. Johns County choices; the right one depends on your priorities on scale, location, and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is closer to the beach?

Nocatee, roughly ten to fifteen minutes from the Ponte Vedra beaches. Bannon Lakes is near St. Augustine, farther from the northern beaches.

Which has more amenities?

Nocatee offers a deeper, more expansive amenity package. Bannon Lakes is smaller with its own amenity center and shopping convenience.

Do both have CDD fees?

Both are master-planned communities with CDD-style and HOA costs. Confirm the specific figures per home before making an offer.

Search Northeast Florida Homes

Browse active listings across Northeast Florida -- from master-planned communities in Nocatee, RiverTown, Tributary, and St. Johns County to coastal homes in Ponte Vedra Beach, Jacksonville Beach, Neptune Beach, and Atlantic Beach.